Citizen Action Monitor

“I say: Goodbye America; you won’t be missed.” Civil rights lawyer, Guy Saperstein, re his move to France

“I’ve become convinced that America is in terminal decline and that the battle for justice and equity is hopeless.” —

No 2787 by fw, October 10, 2021—

Guy Saperstein

“My wife and I have spent sixty years fighting for social justice in America and trying to be good citizens, me as a civil-rights lawyer who litigated — and won — the largest race, age, and disability employment discrimination cases in American history, and my wife as a teacher, social worker, healthcare activist and philanthropist. I retired at fifty-one, having built an enormously lucrative practice, never losing a case as I pursued legal restitution on behalf of clients who had gotten the short end of the stick. I was the very embodiment of the American Dream. But over the decades, I’ve become convinced that America is in terminal decline and that the battle for justice and equity is hopeless. The reasons are multiple.” —Guy Saperstein, Scheerpost

Guy Saperstein: In 1972, he founded a law firm in Oakland which became the largest plaintiffs civil rights law firm in America, in the process successfully prosecuting the largest race, sex and age discrimination class actions in American history. Guy also prosecuted False Claims Act cases against Lockheed Missiles & Space Co. regarding satellite surveillance systems, and against Raytheon, Boeing and TRW regarding the sham National Missile Defense Program.  He is the author of “Civil Warrior: Memoirs of a Civil Rights Attorney.”

Below is my repost of Guy Saperstein’s goodbye letter to America. His reasons are indeed multiple – and blunt and convincing. I have added to the repost my subheadings (bold and italicized), text highlighting, some bulleted formatting, and images.

To read Saperstein’s original piece on Scheerpost’s website, click on the following linked title. Readers’ comments at the bottom of the goodbye letter are worth a look.

**********

Why I’m Leaving America by Guy Saperstein, Scheerpost, October 7, 2021

After six decades fighting for social justice and enjoying the embodiment of the American Dream, this couple is moving on from a lost nation.

America can’t afford to lose too many archetypical couples like the Saperstein’s

My wife and I have spent sixty years fighting for social justice in America and trying to be good citizens, me as a civil-rights lawyer who litigated — and won — the largest race, age, and disability employment discrimination cases in American history, and my wife as a teacher, social worker, healthcare activist and philanthropist. I retired at fifty-one, having built an enormously lucrative practice, never losing a case as I pursued legal restitution on behalf of clients who had gotten the short end of the stick.

The battle for justice and equity in America is hopeless

I was the very embodiment of the American Dream. But over the decades, I’ve become convinced that America is in terminal decline and that the battle for justice and equity is hopeless. The reasons are multiple.

America is no longer leading the world in innovation

America once led the world in innovation. No more. We don’t even have one mile of high-speed rail, unless you count Disneyland. China has 30,000, and counting. Which country do you think is prepared to prosper in the next century?

America can’t even keep its roads repaired

We can’t even keep our roads repaired. America’s roads are a mess, many as bad as any Third World country. In fact, that is what America is becoming — a Third World country.

How can it be that 75 million Americans voted for a failure in everything he tried?

The battle is lost. America is in terminal decline and nearly 75 million Americans seem to be willing to pull it down further. How can it be that so many millions voted for a man who failed in everything he ever tried—

    • a man who started more than a score of businesses and every one failed,
    • who cheated repeatedly on three wives before each marriage failed,
    • who is despised by even members of his own family,
    • who went out of his way nearly every day to show that he is a racist and a sexist,
    • a man who has been caught, according to the Washington Post, in more than 30,000 lies in just the four years he was president,
    • who cheated at nearly everything, including golf,
    • how is it that such a man is held up as a paragon of virtue by nearly half of the electorate?

Something has gone seriously off the rails. 

“America is not now — and has never been — a representative democracy…”

I can no longer bear the chest-thumping triumphalism of the No-Nothing Party*. I can’t stand the self-congratulatory promotion of the hoary notion of American exceptionalism. People who think America is the greatest in all things are people who simply have never been anywhere else. America is not now — and has never been — a representative democracy and won’t be in my lifetime and probably not in yours, either.

    • Biden won by 7.3 million votes — a smashing win, right? — but if just 43,000 votes in a few states had switched, Donald Trump would still be president today.
    • In California, Governor Gavin Newsom could have received 49% of the vote in the recall election and have lost and some Republican hack could have received 18% and won.
    • And because each state has two senators, 18% of the electorate elects 51% of senators. Explain that to Cleisthenes.** [*The No-Nothing Party – “When we look at the GOP of 2016, it seems very much as though we are witnessing a new version of the Know Nothings of the 1850s. One can only hope that this time it is equally short-lived.”] [**Cleisthenes was an ancient Athenian lawgiver credited with reforming the constitution of ancient Athens and setting it on a democratic footing in 508 BC.]

American right-wingers are now engaged in an attack on voting itself

We now have an active right-wing attack on voting itself, much of it racially motivated, but imperiling us all.

The filibuster threatens to make America ungovernable

And then, alas, we have the filibuster, which has almost made America ungovernable.

America – a nation of raging crackpots

I want out.

    • I’m tired of waking up to some crackpot ranting that COVID is a hoax,
    • or vaccines don’t work,
    • or masks are an assault on freedom,
    • or that the 2020 election was stolen and Joe Biden is not really President,
    • or that January 6 was just a peaceful gathering of fun-loving people.

Despite irrefutable evidence, Trump supporters continue to believe he won the election – and worse

While Trump has been diminished, we are surrounded by his supporters — Americans who voted for one of the most despicable men who ever strut upon the American stage, most of his supporters continue to believe — with no evidence — that he won.

    • Most prefer superstition to science,
    • many would apparently rather die than wear a mask or take a vaccine, and
    • tens of millions believe cockamamie conspiracies.
    • These people are not going away.

America’s medical Establishment has Washington in its pocket

This woebegone predicament is likely to get worse. Moreover, our priorities as a nation seem perilously upside down. We spend more than twice the amount for healthcare as any developed nation and get the crappiest healthcare system in the world because the medical Establishment — mainly the drug companies — has Washington in its pocket. And that includes Biden.

America has the worst economic disparities in the world

We have among the worst economic disparities in the world — which are getting worse — a hollowed-out middle class, money overwhelming politics, and even the Democrats unable to do anything about any of this.

“The forces of imperial expansion in America are robust and thriving despite the defeats of the past half-century”

We are exiting Afghanistan, which is good, but the forces of the American imperium, which includes many Democrats, are actively bemoaning the fact that Afghans might actually rule Afghanistan.

    • We still have a military budget almost ten times bigger than any other nation on earth and nearly 900 military bases girdling the globe.
    • China, the big bogeyman, has none.
    • China is taking over the world at amazing speed because they are strategic, not just belligerent.
    • If you think the expensive debacle of Afghanistan and Iraq will mean any rethinking of American foreign policy or scaling down our massive defense apparatus, you are going to be sorely disappointed.
    • The forces of imperial expansion in America are robust and thriving despite the defeats of the past half-century.

America’s downward slide is terminal

If I were a young man, I might stay, but after fifty-plus years of social struggle, I think I have a right to take a rest, enjoy my success and have some fun with my family. America’s downward slide is terminal, and I do not have the energy or influence to have a major impact.

Why Guy Saperstein chose to move to France

I’m moving to France, which has a vibrant middle-class, a real labor movement and twenty times less violent crime than America.

I say: Goodbye America; you won’t be missed.

**********

FAIR USE NOTICE – For details click here

NOTE: Any ads appearing on Citizen Action Monitor are put here without my knowledge, approval, or endorsement, and I receive no payment for them.

%d bloggers like this: