Citizen Action Monitor

In response to “thousands” of emails, Elizabeth May reassures Jewish community over two proposed Party resolutions

Which prompted this comment from a reader: “I am going to have to reconsider my membership in the Green Party…”

No 1718 Posted by fw, July 5, 2016

“Thousands of emails!” YIKES! — the sheer number is in itself intimidating. No sense of proportionality — just like the Israeli military.

Independent Jewish Voices was bang on with its characterization of the pro-Israel lobby as “bullying.”

For background to this story, see Pro-Israel lobby attacks Green Party over its call to revoke charitable status of Jewish National Fund posted on June 29, 2016. Here’s the introduction to that post:

“The pro-Israel lobby suddenly launched vicious, defamatory attacks on IJV and the Greens. They want to defeat the [Green’s] resolution against the JNF and another one supporting the tactic of Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions and intimidate the Greens into never supporting Palestinian rights again…. Despite the pro-Israel lobby’s efforts to intimidate the Greens, it appears likely that both resolutions supporting Palestinian human rights will be deliberated on at the convention in August—whether the pro-Israel lobby likes it or not.” —Tyler Levitan, IJV

The bold highlighted parts of Ms. May’s letter, reposted below” are very telling. (My highlighting). Is it also telling that I was unable to find a copy of Ms. May’s letter on the Green Party’s website?


Elizabeth May Responds to Complaints from Jewish Community  by B’Nai Brith, [July, 2016?]

“Thank you for writing about the proposed resolutions to the Green Party of Canada convention.  I appreciate you taking the time to share your views. In my work in Parliament, I have raised human rights concerns about many nations, but not Israel.  I point this out only to provide context to the CIJA email that suggests the Green Party is singling out Israel. That said, our members come up with resolutions independently. I am not – nor is anyone in the leadership of the party – in charge of resolutions. Nor do we know ahead of time what resolutions will come forward.

“The Green Party resolution process is very different from other parties.  We do not have any screening process. Resolutions of all kinds go forward for a vote. Until the convention in August in Ottawa, we will not know if there is sufficient support to change our current policy.

“The Green Party of Canada opposes the use of Boycott, Divestment and Sanction tactics to influence the policies of the Netanyahu government. Some members wish to change that policy.  That is their right as members.

“The resolution relating to the Jewish National Fund is more problematic. There are clearly a number of problems with the draft resolution. [Note that the problem is not with JNF, it’s with the draft resolution].

“I had a very productive and respectful meeting with Josh Cooper, CEO of JNF Canada, to talk about the resolution. I have invited JNF Canada to participate in the convention and speak to the resolution if it comes to the convention floor.  It may well be defeated in on-line voting and never make it to a debate.

Thank you again for taking the time to write.


Elizabeth May, OC

Member of Parliament

Saanich-Gulf Islands

Leader of the Green Party of Canada

FAIR USE NOTICE – For details click here

%d bloggers like this: