Citizen Action Monitor

TransCanada hires dirty tricks PR consultants to discredit opponents of Energy East pipeline project

Dirty tricks campaign will unleash 35,000 fake grassroots supporters of Energy East

No 1194 Posted by fw, November 20, 2014

“More than 50 Edelman and TransCanada staff would be devoted to the Washington D.C.-based campaign, some of which—primarily the positive PR part—has already been launched. The plan hinges both on mobilizing [fake grassroots] public support for Energy East and discrediting opponents of the pipeline according to the leaked documents, which say ‘It is critical to play offence.’ The company would recruit 35,000 activists to carry their message to the public, claiming it recruited over a million in support of Keystone XL”.—Anastasia Pantsios, EcoWatch

Thanks to Greenpeace for releasing leaked documents detailing TransCanada’s secret public relations and “grassroots advocacy” strategy for its Energy East tar sands pipeline proposal. Greenpeace says the documents show the embattled pipeline company is planning to adopt the tactics employed by the U.S. oil industry to attack environmental advocates in Canada. The strategy was prepared for TransCanada by Edelman, the largest public relations firm in the world.

And thanks to EcoWatch for its clear and concise report of the story, which is accessible by clicking on the following linked title. A copy of the piece is reposted below with added text highlighting of key points.

**********

TransCanada Plots Dirty PR Campaign to Push New Pipeline by Anastasia Pantsios, EcoWatch, November 18, 2014

Burned by the public opposition to its Keystone XL pipeline, which has held up the project for six years, Alberta tar sands company TransCanada has laid out plans to prevent the same thing from happening as it clears the way to build its even longer and larger capacity cross-continental Energy East pipeline.

Greenpeace has leaked documents which reveal the company’s secret strategy, much of which hinges on the same astroturf [fake grassroots] and dirty tricks tactics used by Rick Berman, whose smear campaign against environmentalists was exposed a few weeks ago  by the New York Times. And the firm that prepared the strategy was Edelman, the world’s largest public relations company, which earned itself a blizzard of unfavorable publicity last summer, both for its work for big-time climate deniers and its inept damage control. Edelman’s clients included the American Petroleum Institute and the American Legislative Exchange Counsel (ALEC) and its previous work included an ad campaign for Keystone XL.

The documents, written between May and August 2014, don’t merely suggest promoting the benefits of shipping tar sands oil from Alberta to eastern Canada for export to other countries. They also advocate for the company to “Add layers of difficulty for our opponents, distracting them from their mission and causing them to redirect their resources.” More than 50 Edelman and TransCanada staff would be devoted to the Washington D.C.-based campaign, some of which—primarily the positive PR part—has already been launched.

The plan hinges both on mobilizing public support for Energy East and discrediting opponents of the pipeline according to the leaked documents, which say “It is critical to play offence.” The company would recruit 35,000 activists to carry their message to the public, claiming it recruited over a million in support of Keystone XL.

“It’s not just associations or advocacy groups building these programs in support of the industry,” asserts Edelman in the documents. “Companies like ExxonMobil, Chevron, Shell and Halliburton (and many more) have all made key investments in building permanent advocacy assets and programs to support their lobbying, outreach and policy efforts. TransCanada will be in good company.” Edelman refers to these third parties as “an echo chamber of aligned voices.”

In addition, the documents suggest that the company “apply pressure—intelligently—on opponents, as appropriate,” and to “add layers of difficulty for our opponents, distracting them from their mission and causing them to redirect their resources,” using primarily outside parties to keep their fingerprints off the dirty tricks. They propose using public records, social media, and financial and legal databases to do detailed opposition research on environmental and citizen advocacy groups such as Ecology Ottawa, Avaaz, Equiterre, Council of Canadians and the David Suzuki Foundation.

“One of the lessons that we have learned on Keystone XL is the importance of holding opponents accountable for the claims they make,” TransCanada spokesperson Shawn Howard told The Guardian of London. “Just as our shareholders and the business community hold our organization accountable for our actions, we too feel a duty to ensure that well-organized global opponents are held to the standard of accountability and transparency. We will not apologize for promoting the value of the industry. We are proud of this project.”

“They have hired the world’s largest PR firm because opposition to Energy East is growing,” responded Andrea Harden, the Council of Canadians’ Energy and Climate Justice Campaigner. “From overflowing town halls to provincial reviews and increasingly critical municipal and First Nation leaders, TransCanada is losing public support despite their heavy-handed advertising and desperate tactics.”

The Council of Canadians points out that Edelman’s Mike Krempasky is listed as the senior counsel for the project “responsible for the overall strategic direction and directly responsible for the success of the campaign.” Krempasky previously apologized when it was revealed he has used fake grassroots bloggers in a Walmart campaign. He was also one of the co-founders of the far-right Tea Party-aligned website Redsdtate.com.

Greenpeace condemned the tactics exposed in the documents it leaked.

“When oil companies create front groups to smear their opponents, they degrade democratic debate,” said Keith Stewart, Greenpeace Canada’s climate and energy campaign coordinator. “Greenpeace may be fierce in the defense of our environment, but we put our names to our statements and publish the research to back them up. We expect oil companies to do the same.”

TransCanada is a multibillion-dollar corporation with the backing of the Canadian government, yet with all that in its favor, they still need Daniel Edelman’s campaign of distraction, disruption and dirty tricks to go forward with this pipeline.” said Greenpeace USA research director Mark Floegel. “Clearly, TransCanada and Edelman both know there’s no good economic or social reason to build new infrastructure for dirty fossil fuels.”

As The Guardian points out, “The documents contain only a fleeting reference to climate change—even though the world’s top scientists have found that most of the world’s fossil fuels must stay in the ground to avoid catastrophic global warming.” Energy East would pump nearly 1.1 million barrels a day of the dirty tar sands bitumen oil, compared to Keystone XL’s 850,000 barrels.

FAIR USE NOTICE – Click on above tab for details

%d bloggers like this: