Citizen Action Monitor

Critics rip flawed plan promising win-win low-carbon growth economy with reduced climate risk – Pt 1: The Plan

Elites with vested interests in economic growth deliver New Climate Economy Report with 10-point Global Action Plan

No 1162 Posted by fw, October 9, 2014

This post has 3 sections: First, an article by the Guardian newspaper, which provides a general overview of the Report. Second, statement of the 10-point Global Action Plan excerpted from the Summary of the Report. Third, a list of the 24 members of the Report’s sponsor, the Global Commission on the Economy and Climate (which I label “the vested interests brigade”).

This post will set the stage for two follow-up critical analyses of the New Climate Economy Report.

First The Guardian article

Climate change report prevent damage by overhauling global economy by Fiona Harvey, The Guardian, September 16, 2014

Reducing emissions can generate better growth than old high-carbon model, says co-author of report, Lord Stern

The world can still act in time to stave off the worst effects of climate change, and enjoy the fruits of continued economic growth as long as the global economy can be transformed within the next 15 years, a group of the world’s leading economists and political leaders will argue on Tuesday.

Tackling climate change can be a boon to prosperity, rather than a brake, according to the study involving a roll-call of the globe’s biggest institutions, including the UN, the OECD group of rich countries, the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank, and co-authored by Lord Stern, one of the world’s most influential voices on climate economics.

The report comes ahead of a UN-convened summit of world leaders on global warming next week at which David Cameron has pledged to lead calls for strong action.

“Reducing emissions is not only compatible with economic growth and development – if done well it can actually generate better growth than the old high-carbon model,” said Stern.

It is his most significant intervention in climate politics since the landmark 2006 Stern review of the economics of climate change, which made the case that tackling climate change as a matter of urgency will be cheaper than attempting to deal with the effects of the problem decades in the future. That report marked a revolution in thinking on global warming, and was a major factor in the agreements forged in Copenhagen in 2009 by which developed and major developing countries for the first time set out joint measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

The economic transformation proposed in the new report will improve the lives of billions, the authors argue, from people suffering from air pollution in crowded cities to farmers struggling with poor soils in developing countries, the authors found. But achieving this change will require strong political action to set limits on carbon dioxide emissions, while promoting alternatives such as renewable energy, sustainable cities, teaching modern farming techniques and better-designed transport.

The world is expected to add billions of people to the global population in the next two decades, and trillions of dollars in economic growth – but if the massive expected growth of developing world cities is poorly managed, and global investment is poured into existing high-carbon infrastructure, then a unique opportunity to change the pattern of prosperity will have been lost, and billions of people will be left the poorer as a result, the report warns.

Stern gave the example of cities, which if designed on public transport can have more efficient economies – because people aren’t spending hours commuting and polluting, with its attendant effects on health – as well as better quality of life and lower carbon emissions.

The energy and climate change secretary, Ed Davey, told the Guardian that the UK has already seen benefits from focusing on clean development, and was committed to helping developing countries do the same. He said: “It has required UK business and international investors to recognise the costs of failure and the benefits of change and it has been sustained by a strong, vocal and committed network of NGOs, pressure groups and activists who have been instrumental in sustaining political will and public acceptance.”

Promoting renewable energy sources is a key feature in achieving economic transformation, the report says.

At next week’s climate summit, the UN secretary general, Ban Ki-moon, will convene heads of state and government from around the world to discuss climate change for the first time since the 2009 Copenhagen conference, which produced the first commitments from major developing countries such as China and India to curb emissions, and marked the first time the US agreed to binding emissions targets, but was widely derided for the scenes of chaos that accompanied it.

Convening world leaders again is a risky strategy, but is seen by the UN as essential to lay the ground for a crunch meeting in Paris next year, at which world governments will attempt to forge a new agreement that will cut global greenhouse gas emissions after 2020, when current pledges run out. The EU has vowed to cut emissions by 40% by 2030, compared with 1990 levels, but is the only major developed country bloc to have laid out clear plans.

Today’s report, the New Climate Economy, from the Global Commission on the Economy and Climate, says that although technological “fixes” to climate change – such as renewable energy, low-carbon fuels, better urban design and better use of agricultural land – are growing fast, they are currently nowhere near enough to produce the transformation needed. As new power stations, cities and transport networks are built today, they are still being engineered on a high-carbon basis – coal-fired power plants, roads rather than public transport, slums without facilities rather than planned developments – and once these are built they lock in high carbon emissions for decades to come. Breaking that cycle requires a coordinated effort, from rich and poor countries, that prioritizes sustainability and penalizes high-carbon growth, for instance through a price on carbon.

Such efforts will come at a price, but this is far outweighed by the benefits in economic growth and improvements in health, the report suggests. For instance, reducing the world’s dependence on coal and other dirty fuels will cut air pollution and remove a key source of strain on healthcare systems.

The Global Commission on the Economy and Climate, launched a year ago by the UK along with six other countries, has involved the World Bank, the International Monetary Fund, the OECD, the International Energy Agency and the UN, as well as several research institutes, and former world premiers. It has been chaired by the Mexican president, Felipe Calderón, and advised by leading economists including Lord Stern and Nobel prize winners Daniel Kahneman and Michael Spence.

Ottmar Edenhofer, chief economist at the Potsdam Institute for Climate Impact Research, and an adviser to the report, said: “Economic growth and emissions reductions can be achieved together, the report clearly confirms … Pricing CO2 is key. The heaven above us today is a waste dump for gases that harm our climate system. Wealthy states are disposing of them, free of charge, at the expense of all of us. If emitting CO2 came at a reasonable price, this would stabilise investors’ expectations so they can push forward the innovation of climate friendly technologies.”

Second – The Global Action Plan

Better Growth, Better Climate: The New Climate Economy Report, published September 2014

The report proposes a 10-point Global Action Plan of key recommendations. The first six recommendations provide the conditions necessary for a strong and credible framework to foster low-carbon and climate-resilient investment and growth. The last four point to vital opportunities for change which can drive future growth and lower climate risk in cities, land use and energy systems.

This asks decision-makers to:

1/ Accelerate low-carbon transformation by integrating climate into core economic decision-making processes. This is needed at all levels of government and business, through systematic changes to policy and project assessment tools, performance indicators, risk models and reporting requirements.

2/ Enter into a strong, lasting and equitable international climate agreement, to increase the confidence needed for domestic policy reform, provide the support needed by developing countries, and send a strong market signal to investors.

3/ Phase out subsidies for fossil fuels and agricultural inputs, and incentives for urban sprawl, to drive more efficient use of resources and release public funds for other uses, including programmes to benefit those on low incomes.

4/ Introduce strong, predictable carbon prices as part of good fiscal reform and good business practice, sending strong signals across the economy.

5/ Substantially reduce capital costs for low-carbon infrastructure investments, expanding access to institutional capital and lowering its costs for low-carbon assets.

6/ Scale up innovation in key low-carbon and climate-resilient technologies, tripling public investment in clean energy R&D and removing barriers to entrepreneurship and creativity.

7/ Make connected and compact cities the preferred form of urban development, by encouraging better-managed urban growth and prioritizing investments in efficient and safe mass transit systems.

8/ Stop deforestation of natural forests by 2030, by strengthening the incentives for long-term investment and forest protection, and increasing international funding to around US$5 billion per year, progressively linked to performance.

9/ Restore at least 500 million hectares of lost or degraded forests and agricultural lands by 2030, strengthening rural incomes and food security.

10/ Accelerate the shift away from polluting coal-fired power generation, phasing out new unabated coal plants in developed economies immediately and in middle-income countries by 2025.

Third – Members of the Global Commission on the Economy and Climate

The New Climate Economy is a product of the Global Commission on the Economy and Climate launched a year ago by the UK along with six other countries, is a major new international initiative to analyze and communicate the economic benefits and costs of acting on climate change. Chaired by former President of Mexico Felipe Calderón, the 24-member Commission comprises former heads of government and finance ministers and leaders in the fields of economics and business. Here’s the list of members —

  1. Felipe Calderón (Chair) Former President of Mexico, and Visiting Fellow, Kennedy School of Government, Harvard University – Mexico
  2. Ingrid Bonde Chief Financial Officer and Deputy Chief Executive Officer, Vattenfall (energy corporation) – Sweden
  3. Sharan Burrow General Secretary, International Trade Union Confederation — Australia
  4. Chen Yuan Vice Chairman of the National Committee of the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference, and former Chairman of the China Development Bank — China
  5. Helen Clark Administrator, UN Development Progamme, and former Prime Minister of New Zealand
  6. Luísa Diogo (Vice-Chair) Former Prime Minister of Mozambique, and Chairperson of the Board of Directors, Barclays Bank Mozambique — Mozambique
  7. Daniel L. Doctoroff President and CEO of Bloomberg LP — US
  8. Gopalakrishnan Executive Vice-Chairman, Infosys and President, Confederation of Indian Industry — India
  9. Angel Gurría Secretary-General of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development — Mexico
  10. Chad Holliday Chairman, Bank of America — US
  11. Sri Mulyani Indrawati Managing Director and Chief Operating Officer, The World Bank, and former Finance Minister of Indonesia — Indonesia
  12. Caio Koch-Weser Vice Chairman, Deutsche Bank Group and Chair of the European Climate Foundation — Germany
  13. Ricardo Lagos Former President of Chile, and Professor at Large, Watson Institute for International Studies, Brown University — Chile
  14. Michel M. Liès Chief Executive Officer for the Swiss Re Group — Luxembourg
  15. Trevor Manuel Minister and Chairperson of the South African Planning Commission, and former Finance Minister — South Africa
  16. Takehiko Nakao President, Asian Development Bank — Japan
  17. Eduardo Paes Mayor of Rio De Janeiro, and Chair of the C40 — Brazil
  18. Annise Parker Mayor of Houston — US
  19. Paul Polman Chief Executive Officer, Unilever — Netherlands
  20. Nemat Shafik Deputy Governor of the Bank of England and former Deputy Managing Director, International Monetary Fund — Egypt / UK / US
  21. Nicholas Stern (Vice-Chair) IG Patel Professor of Economics and Government, London School of Economics and Political Science — UK
  22. Jens Stoltenberg UN Special Envoy on Climate Change, and former Prime Minister of Norway — Norway
  23. Maria van der Hoeven Executive Director, International Energy Agency — France
  24. Zhu Levin President and Chief Executive Officer, China International Capital Corporation — China

FAIR USE NOTICE – Click on above tab for details

%d bloggers like this: