Citizen Action Monitor

Why is a serious discussion about the destructiveness of capitalism off the table for activists?

Capitalism = Ecocide

No 839 Posted by fw, August 26, 2013

As a nominal member of the community, I recently participated in the kickoff exercise of its major new initiative to defeat Harper’s anti-democratic agenda in the 2015 election. The first step in the process was to invite members to help shape the campaign’s action plan by indicating their level of support for pre-selected actions. In reviewing the pre-selected list, and subsequently, the compiled results of respondents’ choices, I noticed one glaring omission (glaring to me, anyway) from both – the exclusion of our destructive capitalist system. It is highly unlikely this omission was deliberate; it was probably just taken for granted that capitalism is a given . Moreover, to include it would probably just provoke a firestorm of angry dissent from the majority of the community.

Although Mickey Z’s anti-capitalism article below really says nothing new about the destructive nature of capitalism, the message bears repeating periodically, if for no other reason than to remind us that the remedial efforts humanity makes to address our other grave problems will fall far short of the mark until we begin to have a serious debate about capitalism, the primary underlying threat to our very survival.

To read Mickey Z’s original piece, click on the following linked title. Or read a modified version below with added subheadings.

Capitalism Cannot Be Reformed by Mickey Z., World News Trust, August 23, 2013

capitalism-photoThe essence of capitalism is to turn nature into commodities and commodities into capital.”–Michael Parenti

US is a theocracy with myth of capitalism firmly entrenched on the throne

While anyone paying an iota of attention could recognize that “separation of church of state” is more honored in the breach here in the Home of the Brave™, I’d further submit that the good ol’ U S of A is a genuine theocracy — with the myth of capitalism firmly entrenched on the throne.

Even most activists willingly and counterproductively genuflect at the altar of profit margins.

Few so-called radicals question capitalism’s primacy

Just like the mainstream folks they deride, so-called radicals parrot homilies passed down to them by their corporate commissars. Capitalism, we’re conditioned to believe, may need the occasional tweak and sometimes an overhaul but hey, it’s better than anything else out there!

Destructiveness of capitalism laid bare

All of the above came to my mind as I re-read a pamphlet called The Inefficiency of Capitalism: An Anarchist View (2003). The author (Brian Oliver Sheppard) opted to eschew the “usual, moralistic leftist critique of capitalism.” Instead, he tackled it “head on, on its own turf — economics.”

While I’d question how “anarchist” his pamphlet is, Sheppard does highlight ten of the “most outstanding inefficiencies of capitalism”: product duplication, systemic unemployment, cost-shifting, waste of unsold goods, the inefficiency of hierarchies, planned obsolescence, price gouging, creation of false desires, parasitic “jobs,” and inefficient distribution patterns.

I’m not here to debate the usefulness of this list, however. Instead, I’m asking all of you to see past the economic subterfuge because such myopic critiques inherently imply that capitalism can be reformed.

Capitalism = ecocide

Prices may be controlled, wages raised, products made to last longer, etc. etc. etc. — but what all this ignores is that capitalism = ecocide.

Understanding capitalism and explaining its destructiveness to others does not require an advanced degree or superior insight. This isn’t about vague, inapplicable concepts like “good” or “evil” and it certainly has nothing to do with the fantasies bandied about by deluded economics professors.

It’s all about design.

Capitalism is anti-life

Capitalism is an economic system based on perpetual growth and the relentless exploitation of what we’ve come to call “natural resources.” By definition, such an approach is unsustainable, cannot be reformed, and is thus, anti-life.

To gain access to and control of resources, capitalism requires brutal, sustained military interventions (or the threat thereof). The U.S. Department of Defense, for example, is the world’s largest military power and the planet’s worst polluter and eats up 54 percent of U.S. taxpayer dollars.

Military interventions (or the threat thereof) lead to wars, war crimes, the propping up of authoritarian regimes, poverty and repression, environmental devastation, and eventually… corporate dominion over resources.

Capitalism is the predatory pursuit of profit

Capitalism — in its predatory pursuit of profit — requires humans to dominate humans and humans to dominate non-humans and humans to dominate the landscape… until there’s nothing left.

Resources are finite. They cannot/will not be replicated in a laboratory. Exploiting, poisoning, and consuming the ecosystem alters the delicate and symbiotic balance of the natural world — which only leads to further devastation of our shared landbase.

Capitalism conditions us to be compliant, ill-informed consumers

Capitalism requires constant consumption. Hence, humans are re-programmed into compliant, ill-informed consumers. Pervasive propaganda/public relations keep consumers consuming, workers working, and repressors repressing (explaining why middle class cops pepper spray activists instead of joining up with them).

To be anti-capitalist is to…

While other economic systems may address some of the vast human inequalities inherent in a capitalist society, unless such a system is designed in synchronicity with our shared ecosystem, it will do nothing to prevent the looming economic/social/environmental collapse, thus…

  • To be anti-capitalist is to look beyond the next fiscal quarter, beyond national boundaries, and beyond the corporate propaganda.
  • To be capitalist is to ignore reality. To be capitalist is to pretend that technology is neutral, humans can “control” nature, and the playing field is even.
  • To be anti-capitalist is to see past skin color, gender, ethnicity, sexual preference, ability/disability, age, “class,” or species.
  • To be capitalist is to prize shareholders over sharing, commodities over communities.
  • To be an anti-capitalista is to comprehend that a system based on growth at all costs is anti-life. To be anti-capitalist is to be anti-ecocide.
  • To be capitalist is to voice support for a toxic, poisoned, clear-cut landbase ravaged by unremitting war, disease, inequality, repression, incarceration, and discrimination.
  • To be anti-capitalist is to bravely see past the façade, own up to the myriad global crises, and have a bold new vision for the future — a future that extends well beyond today’s closing bell on Wall Street.
  • To be anti-capitalist is to recognize the urgent need to begin the process of creating a new system — a system not for sale to the highest bidder; not based on celebrity, material consumption, physical beauty, or military conquest; a system that promotes unity and collective action while maintaining individuality and independence; a system that challenges us to think for ourselves and about others; a system that understands the connection between human behavior and non-human life.
  • To be a capitalista is to act as if we are the last generation of humans.
  • To be an anti-capitalista is to re-imagine our relationship with the natural world.

Which side are you on, comrades? The future is waiting on your decision.


Mickey Z. is the author of 11 books, most recently the novel Darker Shade of Green. Until the laws are changed or the power runs out, he can be found on an obscure website called Facebook. Anyone wishing to support his activist efforts can do so by making a donation here.

© — Share and re-post this story. Please include this copyright notice and a link to World News Trust.

FAIR USE NOTICE: This blog, Citizen Action Monitor, may contain copyrighted material that may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. I claim no ownership of such materials. Such material, published without profit, is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues. It is published in accordance with the provisions of the 2004 Supreme Court of Canada ruling and its six principle criteria for evaluating fair dealing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


This entry was posted on August 26, 2013 by in information counterpower and tagged , .
%d bloggers like this: