Citizen Action Monitor

Getting arrested may be easiest way for citizens to have say in Line 9 convoluted official process

Complaints about process raised by ordinary citizens, City of Hamilton, emergency responders, First Nations Chiefs of Ontario, Council of Canadians, and Hamilton 350 Committee

No 825 Posted by fw, August 11, 2013

“Occupying pipeline hubs and highways that could get you arrested may turn out to be an easier way for citizens to have a say in the controversial plans to use an aging pipeline to ship diluted bitumen through Hamilton.  As some opponents plan another demonstration next week, others have been pulling their hair out trying to negotiate the convoluted official process to just submit a letter of comment. The city was among those who succeeded and it has filed some strong objections with the National Energy Board (NEB).”Hamilton CATCH News

Challenging Line 9, Hamilton CATCH, August 9, 2013

Convoluted official process

Occupying pipeline hubs and highways that could get you arrested may turn out to be an easier way for citizens to have a say in the controversial plans to use an aging pipeline to ship diluted bitumen through Hamilton.  As some opponents plan another demonstration next week, others have been pulling their hair out trying to negotiate the convoluted official process to just submit a letter of comment. The city was among those who succeeded and it has filed some strong objections with the National Energy Board (NEB).

“Swamp The Courts” protest rally planned to coincide with court appearance of charged “trespassers”

The demonstration has been called for 11 am next Wednesday (August 14) to coincide with the court appearances of thirteen individuals charged with trespassing last month at the Westover pumping station of Enbridge Inc. The “swamp the courts” rally will start at the MacNab Street HSR terminal and proceed to the John Sopinka courthouse.

Website glitch frustrates citizens, forces NEB to extend filing deadline by one week to August 13

In advance of this, those who obtained official permission last May from the NEB to submit written comments have now been granted a one-week extension to August 13 after many were blocked by a malfunctioning website e-filing system as well as the refusal of the NEB to accept email attachments instead of on-line submissions.

Even a resident who has spent 40 years of his life as a computer systems analyst was frustrated by the NEB’s on-line software. “I attempted to submit my Letter of Comment on Aug 4, 5 and 6 and for all of this time the NEB Letter of Comment submission application malfunctioned on the last step with the error message ‘English Livelink unavailable’,” says Dave Carson of Dundas. “I tried this application several times, using different web browsers to confirm that the problem was not at my end. As a result of this failure I had to fax in my letter, an uncertain process which does not receive any acknowledgement.”

Hamilton’s filing challenges Enbridge’s refusal to address recent pipeline failures

Comments filed by the city focus on potential spills from the 38-year-old Line 9 that could affect local water supplies and damage ecological sensitive areas such as wetlands and streams in rural Hamilton. They also challenge the refusal of Enbridge to provide information on recent failures of the company’s pipelines such as the 3 million litre rupture that contaminated 60 km of Michigan’s Kalamazoo River in July 2010.

Enbridge now seeking permission to pipe cancer-causing chemicals through Line 9

That pipe carried bitumen diluted with cancer-causing chemicals such as benzene, something that Enbridge is now seeking permission to transport through Line 9. The city’s letter suggests a spill into one of the several local streams crossed by Line 9 would significantly threaten drinking water supplies in multiple cities.

“A recently-completed event-based modeling scenario in western Lake Ontario suggested that a release into the Sixteen Mile Creek of benzene could reach the municipal water intakes of Halton Region, the Woodward intake in Hamilton, and the Lorne Park intake in Mississauga at significant threat levels,” notes the letter. “Enbridge should strive to convey a higher confidence to municipalities that their spill response programme is better developed and subject to continual improvement, given historical events and future potentials in that this is an older pipeline with unproven expectations as to its abilities to convey a product with characteristics much different from original intended use.”

Enbridge balks at request from emergency responders for essential job-related information

The letter notes the company “is not prepared to provide municipal emergency responders with the level of information that would enable these first responders to properly plan and prepare for the most effective coordinated response in the event of a pipeline-related emergency.”

It also recommends the installation of shut-off valves “where the pipeline crosses watersheds in the [city], including the Sheffield-Rockton Complex and other provincially-significant wetlands and environmentally-sensitive areas,” and it calls on the NEB to require Enbridge to obtain municipal approvals and pay development charges and other fees to Hamilton if the project is allowed to proceed.

Filing by First Nations’ “Chiefs of Ontario” raises troubling legal issues

Line 9 also directly affects more than a dozen First Nations whose traditional territorial rights are a significant issue. Some have intervenor status that allows them to participate in the hearings expected this fall, but the comment filed this week by “Chiefs of Ontario” raises troubling issues, while emphasizing that each First Nation will ultimately speak for itself.

The chiefs group notes that Line 9 was built before the 1982 Constitution Act when “Canadian legal recognition of First Nations rights was vastly different” and “there was no acceptance of a constitutional duty to consult and accommodate First Nations in the event of proposed projects” likely to affect their lands or rights. They suggest the NEB has the opportunity to respect those rights “and to re-set the relationship with affected First Nations on terms that are agreeable to First Nations.”

NEB refuses to grant Council of Canadians “intervenor status”

A submission from the local chapter of the Council of Canadians challenges the NEB’s refusal to grant intervenor status to its national office.

“The Hamilton Chapter is volunteer based and has very few resources. Had the National Office been included, they could have hired experts and spoke to the impacts to further represent us. Denying the Council of Canadians to participate effectively is not fair.”

Hamilton 350 Committee objects to NEB’s decision to exclude climate change concerns

Comments from the Hamilton 350 Committee reiterate the citizen group’s objections to the decision of the NEB to not consider effects on climate change and increased tar sands extraction.

“It is unreasonable to exclude these crucial matters, and to do so will certainly result in a deeply flawed and grossly inadequate examination of the full impact of the Line 9 proposals,” the group states. “Approving the transport of diluted bitumen will encourage increased extraction and refining activities, resulting in significant greenhouse gas release and damaging climatic consequences.”

FAIR USE NOTICE: This blog, Citizen Action Monitor, may contain copyrighted material that may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. I claim no ownership of such materials. Such material, published without profit, is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues. It is published in accordance with the provisions of the 2004 Supreme Court of Canada ruling and its six principle criteria for evaluating fair dealing.

2 comments on “Getting arrested may be easiest way for citizens to have say in Line 9 convoluted official process

  1. 真空吸盘
    July 3, 2015

      柱塞 混合器 泵公司管理者应该随时保持备战状态,永远’战战兢兢,如履薄冰’。这样的柱塞泵公司才能生存。’不打无把握之仗’是事业必需的规则 卷板机 ,是管理者必备的性格品质。   1999年,陈天桥靠他借来的50万元走上了公司之路。2005年,32岁的陈天桥就成为 折弯机 内地首富。短短六年间,他一手创建的盛大网络资产已超过百亿元,并成为中国最大的互联网厂家和世界最大的网络游戏工作室之一。   盛大之所以能取得如此巨大的成功,忧患意识是它最好的利器。在外人看来,盛大手里似乎有花不完的钱,它的财务状况足够健康。按照陈天桥自己的描述,盛大没有银行贷款,没有应收账款,混合器,每天的现金收入超百亿万元。但陈天桥的心里一直认同比尔

  2. wood frame eyeglasses
    November 16, 2014

    in terms of basames wholesale review shed fulin sunglasses ding weight it takes much greater than eating right to get fit. despite the fact that eating the most efficientway is terribly vital, this is also importantthat yo ic! berlin eyeglasses u justget a fewexercise. Alalthoughweight reduction is one advantage of exercising, the truth that you are going to even

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 124 other followers

%d bloggers like this: