Citizen Action Monitor

Enbridge’s misleading graphics in its Northern Gateway video ads draw fire from citizens and community groups

Company quickly alters widely distributed ads showing hundreds of kilometres of BC islands missing from proposed tanker route

No 548 Posted by fw, August 16, 2012

Enbridge Pipeline and Tankers: Competition Bureau Asked to Investigate Deceptive Northern Gateway Marketing by Enbridge, Press Release: Lori Waters, August 16, 2012

Saanichton, BC — (Marketwire -08/16/12)-

Citizen complaint filed with Competition Bureau, and Advertising Standards Canada

A BC woman who designs scientific graphics for a living today filed two formal complaints with the federal Competition Bureau, and Advertising Standards Canada, claiming Enbridge is misleading the public with promotional videos that have erased the numerous and intricate web of more than 1000 square kilometres of islands along the proposed Northern Gateway tanker route. Since the Vancouver Island resident made a corrected graphic two days ago showing Enbridge’s omission, it has gone viral with over 8,000 shares. The graphics have been remixed by citizens and community groups into videos, infographics and photos.

Enbridge removes one video, makes disclaimer in the other

The original video advertisements appeared on Enbridge’s website and YouTube [see links to these videos at the end of this post] and are among the company’s key promotional pieces for their pipeline project and have been used by several media outlets in stories since late last year. Since the controversy broke in the media yesterday, Enbridge hastily beat a partial retreat, removing the offending image from one of their videos, and making the existing disclaimer more prominent in another. The offending video remains a prominent feature on the company’s website, and is being widely shared on the Internet and through social media.

Ad controversy does not help Enbridge’s “culture of deviance” image that has already shaken public confidence in its pipeline operation

The controversy comes amid shaken public confidence in Enbridge as a result of a scathing US National Transportation Safety Board report that concluded Enbridge’s pipeline operations showed a “culture of deviance” on safety procedures.

“What Enbridge has done is to distort the maps in its promotional videos to erase numerous islands and twisting passages so that tanker route appears much safer than it is,” said Lori Waters, who has a graduate degree specializing in scientific animation and owns a biomedical communications company. “Enbridge continues to offer this misleading video to the public, and it can’t be trusted. Quickly pulling their fake map out of one ad, and slapping a disclaimer at the front of the other ad confirms for me that something weird is going on, and I’ve included that in with my complaints. “

Side-by-side graphics highlight Enbridge’s misleading depiction

Waters is the mastermind behind a corrected graphic that has gone viral on social media over the past two days. She put together a few simple slides showing Enbridge’s depiction of the tanker route along with the same graphic that includes the islands that were erased and a Google Earth version of the same views.

Enbridge tries to mend its already damaged public image

As a result of the negative attention, Enbridge responded yesterday afternoon by partially altering the ads and stating to the media that the video was meant to be “illustrative” and that other videos, and their regulatory filings, contained accurate maps.

“I thought it was important to set the record straight”, said Waters. “It’s not acceptable to make a misleading video and then hide behind a claim that it’s just an illustration, or that the map is not to scale. The rest of the coastline is drawn fairly accurately – they’ve just deliberately eliminated all the islands. Frankly, it’s ridiculous that Enbridge is now suggesting that the viewer should scramble around and look at documents they’ve filed in a government registry or in other videos to find a true picture, when the most prominent image that they’ve provided is false. The fact is that the illustration is deceptive and that’s why I’m asking for a formal investigation.

Citizens respond to petition campaign telling Enbridge to stop misleading the public

The graphic was picked up by groups opposed to the tar sands development project and rapidly went viral. SumOfUs, a world-wide, citizen-driven campaign organization dedicated to watchdogging corporate practices, posted the graphic online with a petition to Enbridge asking them to take the videos down from their website. As of this morning, over 12,000 people had signed the petition in about 12 hours. [It’s not too late to sign the petition — just click on the above link].

The complaints to Competition Bureau and Advertising Standards Canada are at: https://www.box.com/s/16509628de91608d12e1

The original, unaltered Enbridge videos are here:

Fair Use Notice: This blog, Citizen Action Monitor, may contain copyrighted material that may not have been specifically authorized by the copyright owner. Such material, published without profit, is made available for educational purposes, to advance understanding of human rights, democracy, scientific, moral, ethical, and social justice issues. It is published in accordance with the provisions of the 2004 Supreme Court of Canada ruling and its six principle criteria for evaluating fair dealing

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: